The Best Restaurants in Amelia Island
Amelia Island is a dining paradise with options ranging from fine dining to casual waterfront eateries. Whether it’s your first visit or you’re a seasoned local, this guide will help you explore the island’s unmatched restaurant experiences. Let’s dive into the best restaurants in Amelia Island, organized by cuisine and specialty.
Amelia Island is one of our favorite beach getaways. Located in northern Florida on the Atlantic, the island has more in common with the Georgia and South Carolina low-country than it does with the typical white sand beaches and high rise condos you’ll find in other parts of Florida. We make the trip almost every year and have tried a ton of restaurants on the island. This guide will give you our list of favorite restaurants in Amelia Island.
The Best Restaurants in Amelia Island
There’s no shortage of fantastic places to eat on Amelia Island. Known for its fresh seafood and eclectic flavors, the island’s restaurants ahve something for everyone. Our favorites are The Patio at 5th & Ash for live music and fantastic craft cocktails, Timoti’s for casual seafood, and Lagniappe for cajun dishes. Read on for the rest of our list.
Salt
Located in the Ritz Carlton, Salt is a AAA 5-Diamond gem specializing in fresh seafood. The à la carte menu features delights like the Salt Brick Steak and Artisan Cheese Experience. With stunning Atlantic Ocean views and refreshing cocktails, it’s the perfect spot for unforgettable celebrations.
David’s Restaurant & Lounge
Amelia Island’s classic steakhouse always gets rave reviews. This is a white tablecloth, extensive wine list, gourmet cuts of Wagyu beef kind or place. David’s is an excellent choice for birthdays and anniversary celebrations, with upscale service and intimate private dining rooms.
If you aren’t in the mood for steak, you can choose from delicious dishes like Lobster Bisque and Chilean Sea Bass. Elevate your meal with exquisite options like Caviar, Grilled Octopus, and Escargot. But, whatever you do, save room for dessert. The Creme Brulee and Affogato are amazing.
Burlingame
Owner and executive chef, Chad Livingston is originally from Fernandina Beach. After perfecting his craft for several years, he moved home where he worked at Salt. Lucky for us, he opened Burlingame in a charming 1947 cottage, giving the interior a sleek modern makeover.
Burlingame’s seasonal menu features favorites like Seafood Gumbo, Blue Crab Cakes and Lamb Bolognese. The relaxed environment and outdoor seating make it ideal for drinks and dinner with friends. Service is also top notch.
Lagniappe
Lagniappe is a Creole term for “a little something extra” and that’s what this place delivers. Executive Chef Brett Heritage blends Southern refinement with French Creole for a unique, elevated menu. You’ll find standout dishes like Salmon Brulee and Lamb Lollipops. But, its not all high brow eating. The L Burger is fantastic and the Po Boy is made with authentic Leidenheimer bread from New Orleans.
My cajun roots were doing a little dance over the Shrimp and Grits. It was absolutely delicious. With a vibrant cocktail bar, extensive wine list, and a welcoming atmosphere, Lagniappe is perfect for special occasions or a relaxed night out. Private dining options, including a courtyard, make it great for events like rehearsal dinners or similar events.
Kitchen 251
Located in the Amelia Island marina, Kitchen 251 needs to be on your list if you love seafood. Chef Michael McCarroll, brings his Louisiana roots and over 30 years of culinary experience to Amelia Island where he infuses a touch of Cajun flair into his dishes.
Dishes like Grouper Tacos, Shrimp and Grits, and Smoked Fish Dip make this a locals favorite. Non-seafood lovers can go for Slow Smoked Pork or Gourmet Burger. Definitely check out the blackboard for the day’s specials featuring the catch of the day. The open-air atmosphere with gorgeous waterfront views is perfect for happy hour or a casual meal.
Timoti’s Seafood Shak
We tried Timoti’s on our very first visit to Amelia Island and loved it so much that we eat here at least once on every visit. This casual dining spot is famous for its seafood basket and hush puppies. Baskets are made to order and can be fried, blackened, or grilled. And don’t sleep on their lobster rolls, crab burgers, and poke bowls. Everything is fresh, and everything is delicious.
There’s no inside seating. Order inside and then head back outside to the covered patio to find a seat. Tables are picnic style so you’ll likely be sharing with other diners. We’ve met some great people from as far away at The Netherlands while waiting for our name to be called at the window. Put Timoti’s at the top of your list of must-try restaurants in Amelia Island. You won’t be disappointed.
The Surf Restaurant & Bar
A surf-themed casual hangout, The Surf has been an Amelia Island institution since 1957. This is the quintessential beach bar and restaurant with live music, ocean breezes and casual seafood bites. The Surf is known for Fish Tacos and casual eats such as Burgers, Flatbreads, and Wings. Its the most chilled beachfront dining experience on our list.
Shuckers Oyster Bar & Grill
Established in 2008, Shuckers Oyster Bar & Grill has grown from its humble beginnings behind a gas station to a popular waterfront dining destination. Known for its fresh oysters and dishes like Bang Bang Shrimp and Fried Green Tomatoes, Shuckers serves traditional Southern fare with a relaxed vibe.
The restaurant’s outdoor seating has beautiful views of the Intracoastal Waterway, making it perfect for casual gatherings or happy hour. With live music and a family-friendly atmosphere, Shuckers is a favorite spot for both locals and visitors alike.
T-Ray’s Burger Station
T-Ray’s Burger Station, a family-owned establishment since 1998, is a local icon housed in a converted gas station. Known for its juicy burgers, fried grouper sandwiches, and Southern breakfast favorites like biscuits and gravy, this spot serves up a little nostalgia with dinner.
T-Ray’s has earned national acclaim, including recognition on USA Today’s list of the 50 Best Burger Joints in America. Open for breakfast and lunch six days a week, it’s a true big crowd pleaser with down-home cooking and friendly service that keeps locals and visitors coming back.
The Tavern – Amelia Island Brewing Company
The Tavern by Amelia Island Brewing Company (AIBC) combines craft beer with upscale comfort food in a family-friendly atmosphere. Established in 2016 as the area’s first fully operational craft brewery, The Tavern quickly became a locals favorite.
Signature dishes like Crispy Brussels with smoked bacon and Tavern Mac & Cheese are favorites. Whether enjoying Fish & Chips or Truffle Tots, diners can expect a menu filled with elevated pub favorites in a relaxed yet vibrant setting.
The Patio at 5th and Ash
The Patio at 5th and Ash is one of our absolute favorite restaurants in Amelia Island. We loved it so much the first time we tried it, we went back two days later. This charming family owned American bistro has a diverse menu featuring everything from seafood and steaks to pasta and daily specials.
Sit outside in the courtyard under the giant oaks dripping with Spanish moss and twinkling lights to enjoy the live music. The patio is still an option during cooler months with the addition of fire pits and heaters. Signature dishes like their slow-braised short rib flatbread and famous meatballs pair beautifully with house-made sangria or bourbon-style Bloody Marys.
Read our recommendations for where to stay on Amelia Island in this article!
Salty Pelican Bar & Grill
Established in 2012, The Salty Pelican Bar & Grill has become one of the favorite waterfront restaurants in Amelia Island. Known for its seafood specialties like blackened grouper tacos, fresh oysters, and fried tuna, the menu also includes casual favorites like burgers and wings.
Their signature cocktails, such as the Ultimate Margarita and Pelican Sunset Punch, are pretty darn good. With stunning sunset views over the Amelia River and a vibrant atmosphere with live music, it’s a perfect spot to unwind. You’ll find both locals and tourists enjoying the food and the views here.
Arte Pizza
We found Arte Pizza on a trip to Amelia Island with our kids when we needed something besides seafood to satisfy 5 hungry kiddos. And we were not disappointed. This spot specializes in authentic Neapolitan-style wood-fired pizzas, handcrafted with fresh, high-quality ingredients.
You’ll find a variety of pizzas, calzones, salads, and Italian specialties, all cooked in a traditional wood-fired oven that gives a smoky flavor and perfectly crisp crust. Located in downtown Fernandina Beach, Arte Pizza is a local favorite for its casual atmosphere and delicious pies. Its a great choice for anyone looking for a relaxed dining experience for lunch or dinner.
España Restaurant & Tapas
España Restaurant & Tapas, located in downtown Fernandina Beach, serves authentic Spanish and Portuguese cuisine in a charming setting. The menu features a variety of hot and cold tapas, fresh seafood, and savory meat entrées, with their paella being the standout dish.
Locals love their homemade sangria and curated list of international and Californian wines. España has multiple dining areas, including a cozy main dining room, an enclosed garden dining room, and a lush outdoor garden. So, you can pick your favorite spot to enjoy your favorite dish.
Wicked Bao
Wicked Bao is one of the local favorite restaurants in Amelia Island. This Asian Fusion restaurant serves authentic Asian street food. Specializing in steamed Taiwanese bao buns, the menu includes flavorful fillings like braised pork belly, bulgogi beef, and buttermilk fried chicken.
You can also pick up small plates like potstickers and chicken satay, along with noodle dishes such as pork ramen. Located in a historic building with both indoor and outdoor seating, Wicked Bao is open for dinner and happy hour, making it a perfect spot for a casual – non-beachy – night out.
Hola! Cuban Cafe
Hola! Cuban Cafe is a family-owned restaurant that celebrates the flavors of Cuba. Their menu features authentic dishes like Cubano sandwiches, Ropa Vieja, and bowls made with slow-roasted meats cooked fresh in-house. Complement your meal with robust Cuban coffee or enjoy wine, prosecco, or beer.
With indoor seating, a dog-friendly patio, and a cozy back porch, Hola! is the perfect spot for breakfast, lunch, or a casual snack. Open Thursday through Sunday, this cafe is an awesome addition to Fernandina Beach’s dining scene.
Twisted Table
Twisted Table, located in downtown Fernandina Beach, is a woman-owned restaurant specializing in fresh and wholesome breakfast, brunch, and lunch offerings. Their menu includes crowd favorites like quiches served all day, breakfast sandwiches, and the popular Blueberry Twisted Toast.
Lavazza coffee options, including espresso and lattes complement the delicious meals. The cozy and inviting atmosphere, combined with fast and friendly service, makes Twisted Table a favorite of locals and visitors.
Your next read
Amelia Island
Amelia Island Coffee
Amelia Island Coffee is a locals favorite in downtown Fernandina Beach. Located in a charming 140-year-old building with exposed brick walls, the café has a sweet and cozy atmosphere, perfect for starting your day or a midday break.
They specialize in locally roasted, single-origin coffee, serving espresso drinks, cold brews, and organic teas. Pair your drink with freshly baked pastries, breakfast sandwiches, or a bagel. With free Wi-Fi and friendly service, Amelia Island Coffee is a favorite for both locals and visitors.
Nana Teresa’s Bake Shop
Nana Teresa’s Bake Shop is well known for its delicious made-from-scratch confections. The bakery makes a wide array of treats, including cupcakes, cookies, pastries, pies, and specialty cakes. They also use imported Belgian and African chocolates, European butter, and farm-fresh eggs. Yum! Their whimsical cupcakes and hand-decorated cookies are popular with visitors and locals.
Vintage Donuts
Vintage Donuts, located on Centre Street in downtown Fernandina Beach, is the cutest old-fashioned donut shop with made-to-order cake donuts. You’ll start with a vanilla cake donut and then you get to add your favorites. Choose a custom glaze, topping, and drizzle for a totally unique combo.
What will your favorite be? Lemon Blueberry with Streusel? Chocolate with Sprinkles and Sea Salt Drizzle? Chocolate with Oreo Drizzle? The possibilities are endless!
DeNucci’s Soft Serve
DeNucci’s Soft Serve, a family-owned ice cream shop near Main Beach, has been delighting Amelia Island since 2010 with its variety of frozen treats. From creamy soft serve custard and hard scoop ice cream to refreshing Dole Whips, there’s something for everyone.
DeNucci’s also serves Nathan’s hot dogs and cold sandwiches, making it a great stop for more than just dessert. You’ll have your choice of indoor or outdoor seating, walk-up windows, a drive-through, and they even have a playground for kiddos. Popular treats include the Banana Split, Mint Chocolate Chip Soft Serve, and the indulgent Pecan Pie Twister.
Get your Free Weekend Travel Planner
This is the exact planner we use when planning a Weekend Getaway!
